Key Points
- PayPal sued over Honey browser extension
- Influencers say millions in commissions stolen
- Case could change affiliate marketing
- Tech giants vs. content creators battle
- Your online shopping might be affected
The Sweet Turned Sour: Honey’s Sticky Situation
Picture this: You build a successful online business. Then, a big tech company swoops in and takes your profits. That’s what Instagram influencer Claudia Jayne Young and many others say PayPal’s Honey is doing.
On January 3, 2025, Young filed a class-action lawsuit. She claims,
Through a simple and incredibly effective scheme, PayPal has, for years, been systematically stealing affiliate marketing commissions from individuals who have built businesses, online personas, and advertising relationships to make a living.
But what’s all the fuss about? Let’s break it down.
Affiliate Marketing 101: The Sweet Deal Gone Wrong?
Affiliate marketing is like super-powered word-of-mouth. Influencers promote products. When their followers buy using special links, influencers get a cut. It’s good for creators, sellers, and buyers. Or it was, until now.
Enter Honey, a browser add-on that finds coupon codes at checkout. Sounds helpful, right? But there’s a catch. The lawsuit says Honey jumps in at the last second. It swaps out the influencer’s link for its own. This means Honey gets the money, not the influencer who did the work.
Tech reviewer Marques Brownlee says,
It involves almost every high-profile creator that I can think of, including myself.”
That’s a lot of people potentially losing money.
PayPal’s Defense
PayPal bought Honey for $4 billion in 2020. They’re not taking these claims lightly. They say Honey is just doing its job: saving people money. A company spokesperson stated,
Honey is free to use and provides millions of shoppers with additional savings on their purchases whenever possible. Honey follows industry rules and practices.
But critics aren’t convinced. They say even when Honey doesn’t find a valid coupon, it still takes the commission. It’s like showing up to a party empty-handed but still taking home leftovers.
The Bigger Picture: David vs. Goliath in the Digital Age
This isn’t just about Honey and PayPal. It’s a classic underdog story playing out online. As big tech companies grow, smaller creators feel squeezed out.
Josh Sanford, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, warns,
If the allegations are borne out as true, they’re going to have made e-commerce harder because it makes vendors and consumers less able to trust each other and less confident that they understand the terms of their transaction.
This case could change how we think about online shopping, content creation, and power in the digital world.
What’s Next? The Future of Affiliate Marketing
As the legal fight goes on, affiliate marketing isn’t standing still. Here are some possible futures:
- New ways to credit multiple steps in a sale
- Using blockchain for clear commission tracking
- A closer look at browser add-ons and shopping tools
- More direct deals between brands and creators
Whatever happens, one thing’s clear: quietly taking a cut of others’ work might soon be over.
Your Move: Smart Shopper or Accidental Helper?
As this drama unfolds in court, we should ask: what’s our role as shoppers? When we use tools like Honey, are we accidentally taking money from creators we like?
It’s not a simple issue. But as the line blurs between helping buyers and hurting creators, it’s worth thinking about on your next online shopping trip.
What do you think? Is Honey helpful or harmful? Tell us in the comments!
Stay Informed
The legal matter involves Claudia Jayne Young filing a lawsuit against PayPal, Inc. and its parent company, PayPal Holdings, Inc. This case is officially designated as Case No. 5:25-cv-00124.
Want to learn more? Check out these resources:
We’ll keep you updated as this story develops. In tech and online shopping, things can change fast!
Experts warn of Russian’s previous deepfake use
Deepfakes use AI to make highly realistic-looking fake images of humans Artificial Intelligence (AI) can “now be used to make images and videos that are fake that look hyper-realistic.” Deepfakes involve “pioneering technology,” which is “used to synthetically alter audio and video to create fake images that appear highly realistic.” [I] New techniques now “allow […]
June 26, 1948: Berlin Airlift
Video of a bony lion in a Chinese enclosure surfaces
55 years ago, the US dropped 5,000 bombs a day for 77 days
Vietnamese long-range artillery detonated tons of explosives On January 21, 1968, the history of the Siege of Khe Sanh began. It is also known as the Battle of Khe Sanh. This historical battle is considered one of the Vietnam War’s most controversial battles. The history of the battle begins at Khe Sanh combat base, located […]
A few of 200+ relics discovered at Shang Dynasty site- Dogs buried alive, wine vessels, a dagger-axe & a gold mask
Recently, at the Shangdu site in Zhengzhou, more than 200 relics were discovered. Discoveries included several gold coverings and a large amount of gold.” The site where the archaeological find occurred was discovered in 2021 and is “a Shang Dynasty noble burial area in the south of East Street, east of Zijingshan Road, and north […]
